An American Tragedy (1931) Starring: Phillips Holmes,
Sylvia Sidney, Frances Dee Directed by Josef von Sternberg Screenplay by Samuel
Hoffenstein Based on the novel An American Tragedy by Theodore Dreiser (New
York, 1925). Produced by Josef von Sternberg Runtime: 96 minutes. USA Black and
White Melodrama, Romance, Pre-Code.
On July 11, 1906, Chester E. Gillette drowned Grace Brown in
a lake in Herkimer County, New York. That murder was the basis of Theodore
Dreiser’s 880-page novel, An American Tragedy, published in 1925. When Paramount
bought the rights, the film was originally planned as the American debut of
Sergei Eisenstein, the renowned Soviet film director; Battleship Potemkin
(1926).
Apparently, Eisenstein was so interested in the project that
he wrote, what the Associate Producer David O. Selznick called “the most moving
script I have ever read." However, B.P. Schulberg, the head of Paramount,
wasn’t so impressed and replaced Eisenstein with Josef von Sternberg.
Eisenstein never did make a Hollywood film and returned to the Soviet Union.
The change in director didn’t change the Hays Office’s
objections to the film and the aspect of the story that dealt with an abortion.
Colonel Jason S. Joy, the Director of the Studio Relations Office, wrote to
Schulberg on April 25, 1931, "If the references to abortion remain in
"American Tragedy"...it will surely tend to eventually open the way
for a more serious development of this subject in pictures." However,
Schulberg wasn’t willing to eliminate Roberta's attempts to secure an abortion
from the film because of an earlier approval given by Father Daniel J. Lord, a
clergyman who collaborated on the draft of the Hays Code. But on July 15, 1931,
Jesse Lasky wrote to Hays agreeing to eliminate the following dialogue, which
refers to abortion: "You went to the druggist who testified here."
"Yes sire." "Anyone else?" "Yes sire, to seven others
before I could get anything at all." "But what you got didn't help,
did it? "No sir."