Ebenezer (2026) starring Johnny Depp, Rupert Grint, Andrea Riseborough, Sam Claflin, Daisy Ridley, Tramell Tillman, Ian McKellen Directed by Ti West. Screenplay by Nathaniel Halpern. Based on A Christmas Carol by Charles Dickens. Produced by Emma Watts. Run time: 116 minutes. Color UK/USA Drama, Christmas
There are several stories that seem to be perennials. How
many films are there based on Little Women, or Jane Eyre, or Sense
and Sensibility? It seems like not too much time goes by before someone is
taking another shot at retelling it. But I would have to say the champion,
outside of perhaps Shakespeare, would be Charles Dickens’ A Christmas Carol.
If you’ve read this blog for while, you should find that we’ve made a slight
cottage industry around Christmas reviewing versions of this story from a
silent retelling A
Christmas Carol (1910) to the 2017 film, The
Man Who Invented Christmas, about the writing of the tale. All of the film
reviews can be found in our Review
Hub - A Christmas Carol.
But my interest in this retelling of the story dates back
to last July, at San Diego Comic-Con. For the first time since attending the
Con, and we’ve been going for nearly 15 years, I was able to walk into Hall H
and see a panel. And what started out as "Directors on Directing" was
interrupted by a disguised Johnny Depp as Ebenezer Scrooge, which was the first
indication I had that this film was made. And being a fan of the story, it was
on my list for the year.
Reviews were not great, and the word mixed maybe the best way to describe them. However, I’m here to say that this retelling, while perhaps not first on my list, was still touching. If you’re not already familiar with the story, then you need to get out more. This is a novella that has never not been in print since it was first published in 1843 and the theme, that we should keep Christmas in our hearts year-round has never gone out of fashion, though it is rarely practiced.
Ebenezer pretty much follows Dicken’s tale, though
there are some changes made along the way, which is true of all versions. Rather
than starting seven years after Jacob Marley’s passing, which the novella does,
we start the day of his death. This actually works to give a little more depth
to the partner’s relationship as like-minded men.
Perhaps the most surprising was Christmas morning. Usually, a boy is called from the window to have a goose or turkey sent to Cratchit’s home, and Scrooge spends the afternoon at his nephew Fred’s Christmas Day party. In this version, the boy is not as remarkable, and the goose is taken by Scrooge to Fred’s house, even though the party was on Christmas Eve. But it is the reunion with his nephew that is perhaps more touching here than I remember in other films. We don’t get the buoyant Scrooge that we often see, but a rather subdued one. A changed man, but not necessarily the second father to Tiny Tim (Freddie Lee-Grey) that Dickens wrote about. Cratchit does come out with a raise to partner the next day, so don’t worry about him.
![]() |
| Johnny Depp as Ebenezer. |
It’s a pretty solid cast through and through. While I couldn’t really tell a British accent from Depp, he still handles the complex character very well. It was nice to see Rupert Grint again, since I hadn’t seen him since his Harry Potter Days. He disappears into the role of Bob Cratchit, Scrooge’s oft-mistreated clerk. Ian McKellen is good in the role of Jacob Marley. Sam Clafin and Daisy Ridley play Fred Scrooge and his wife Clara. Both give memorable performances in their roles.
You have to remember that Ti West is a director who works in
horror, when it comes to the three spirits. The Ghost of Christmas Past (Andrea
Riseborough), the Ghost of Christmas Present (Tramell Tillman) and the Ghost of
Christmas Yet to Come (Robert Strange) and make up and outfits as much in line with
a horror film rather than I’m sure Dickens envisioned them. This is a modern
retelling, so these adornments as well as some of the relationships in the film, are painted with a present-day brush.
This is not a movie for small children, though it is not
overly graphic, which seems to fit with its PG-13 rating. As with all
retellings of A Christmas Carol, this one manages to find its heart in
the right place, though it may get there in a different way than previous takes
on Dickens’ story. However, if you’re in a traditional Christmas mood, this is
perhaps the best such film out this year.


No comments:
Post a Comment